Why does he dismiss my feelings?
Quick answer
He might dismiss your feelings because he gets defensive, doesn’t know how to listen, or doesn’t want to engage. You can’t identify the reason from one comment. Name the behavior and ask for a different response. Repeated mockery, intimidation, or punishment is not a communication quirk you must learn to tolerate.
Two editorial perspectives, not testimony or survey findings. Neither represents all men or all women. For adults 18+; general information, not therapy, medical, legal, or financial advice.
Men’s view
“That’s just how guys communicate” isn’t an excuse. A man may have learned to respond to distress by fixing the problem, minimizing it, or trying to end the conversation. That background can explain a habit. It doesn’t make “you’re being ridiculous” a respectful response to someone he cares about.
Sometimes the listening failure starts with feeling accused. You say, “I felt alone at the party,” and he hears, “You’re a terrible boyfriend.” He then argues about whether he spoke to you for eight minutes or twelve. The facts may deserve discussion, but defending the timeline before acknowledging the hurt can leave you feeling even more alone.
A better response would be, “I didn’t realize you felt left out. Tell me what happened from your side.” The Gottman Institute’s guidance is that understanding should come before advice. Listening first doesn’t mean admitting every accusation or agreeing with every interpretation. It means taking the experience seriously enough to hear it.
If you’re raising the issue, use one example and a request. “When you said I was too sensitive after that joke, I felt brushed aside. Please listen before telling me what I should feel.” You don’t have to deliver it perfectly, but specificity gives the conversation a clearer target.
Then pay attention to his response. Someone willing to learn may ask clumsy questions, get something wrong, and still make a genuine effort. Someone who keeps returning to contempt or calls every concern an attack is showing a more persistent problem.
You can invite a better conversation; you can’t do his listening for him. If every request becomes another reason you’re supposedly impossible, stop searching for the one sentence that will make him care. Change requires participation from the person doing the dismissing, not endless improvements to your delivery.
Women’s view
Having to prove that a feeling exists is exhausting. You describe being hurt, and suddenly you’re explaining why you aren’t dramatic, irrational, or too demanding. By the end of the conversation, the original issue has vanished. You’re defending your right to raise anything at all.
It helps to separate validation from agreement. He can remember the party differently and still say, “I get why that felt lonely.” You can acknowledge his intentions and still say the joke hurt. There doesn’t have to be a winner before either person is treated with care.
Keep the focus on the response you want. “I don’t need you to agree with every part. I need you not to laugh when I say I’m upset.” If he starts debating your personality, bring it back once: “We’re talking about how you responded just now.” You aren’t required to follow every detour.
There is a meaningful difference between a poor response and a pattern that makes it unsafe to speak. A stressed partner might interrupt and later apologize. A partner who threatens you, humiliates you, or punishes you for raising a concern needs a different assessment. Don’t label every disagreement abuse, but don’t downgrade intimidation to ordinary bad communication either.
The National Domestic Violence Hotline offers confidential support and safety planning at thehotline.org or 800-799-7233. If your device is monitored, seek a safer way to contact support. In immediate danger, call 911. You can ask for help without having decided what label fits the relationship or whether you’re ready to leave.
For an otherwise safe relationship, a calm follow-up and possibly qualified couples support can be useful if both people want change. When fear or control is present, seek individual specialist guidance first. You shouldn’t have to become smaller, quieter, or endlessly agreeable to keep an ordinary conversation from turning against you.
Where these perspectives agree and differ
Shared ground
Both perspectives distinguish explanation from excuse. Defensiveness or a lack of listening skills may help explain a dismissive comment, but neither makes it acceptable. The men’s take emphasizes what responsible listening would look like; the women’s take emphasizes the effect of repeatedly having your experience put on trial.
The tension
The practical difference is whether repair is possible and safe. A partner who can hear a specific example, acknowledge the impact, and change offers something to work with. Repeated mockery or intimidation isn’t solved by making your request softer. You don’t need to decide his diagnosis or hidden motive. Decide whether the response is respectful, whether it improves, and whether you can speak without fearing what happens next.
Sources
Sources support the general context; they do not establish any individual’s motives or turn the editorial views into gender survey findings.
What feels most dismissive during a hard conversation?
Be one of the first to vote. Results appear after 10 votes.
Common follow-ups
Is dismissing feelings always gaslighting?
No. A dismissive comment isn’t enough to identify gaslighting or a person’s intent. Repeated attempts to make you doubt your reality are more concerning. Describe the behavior and seek support if you feel confused or unsafe.
Can he validate me without agreeing?
Yes. He can recognize that you felt hurt or alone without sharing your interpretation. Respectful disagreement addresses the issue without mocking the feeling or your right to bring it up.
Have a question you can’t ask your friends?
Send it in. If we take it, you’ll get both sides — not just one opinion.
Comments
Comments are reviewed before they appear. Nothing goes live until an editor has checked it. This is not a live forum.